Play Through the Mistake—Unless You’re in the Trenches

“Keep going.”

My students hear that from me. But they also hear, “Stop. Back up. Let’s work on just that part.” Those instructions might sound contradictory, but they serve two different purposes. Sometimes we’re fixing the playing. Other times, we’re practicing keeping the music moving. Knowing which one you’re doing makes a big difference.

Going Into the Trenches

When something isn’t working, playing the entire song again isn’t always the answer. Sometimes the work is much smaller: the movement from one chord to the next, the placement of one finger, or the moment your strumming hand needs to meet your fretting hand.

This is what I call going deep, or getting into the trenches. We isolate the tiny transition that’s causing trouble and work through it very slowly. Not the whole verse. Not even necessarily a whole measure. Just the movement that needs attention.

Speed isn’t the first goal. First, understand where your body is going and how it gets there.

Slow Enough to Make It Work

If you keep missing the same chord change, slow it down until you can see what’s happening. Which finger moves first? Is another finger lifting farther than it needs to? Are you rushing the landing before your hand knows where to go?

Give yourself time to make the movement cleanly. The goal isn’t to prove you can do it fast once. It’s to make the movement reliable enough that you can use it in the song.

Research offers some support for this approach. In a small study of 17 advanced pianists, more accurate practice was associated with better performance the next day. The strongest performers identified problems, slowed down when needed, and repeated corrected passages until they were stable. That doesn’t prove slow practice alone caused their success, but it supports paying attention to how you practice—not just how long.

This is where the fixes happen. Don’t rush out of the trenches just because the song is more fun to play.

Let the Metronome Keep You Honest

Use a metronome while you work on those small transitions. Set it slow enough that you can play accurately and stay with the beat. Not a tempo you can barely survive—a tempo that gives you room to notice and control the movement.

Without a steady reference, it’s easy to rush through the comfortable parts and hesitate at the difficult ones without realizing it. The metronome helps you hear whether that transition actually fits into the time available.

Take two chords that give you trouble. Practice moving between them with the clicks, leaving enough beats to prepare each change. Listen to the strings and notice unnecessary movement. Once you can make the change consistently and comfortably, increase the tempo a little at a time.

If it falls apart, back off. There’s no prize for setting the metronome faster than your hands are ready to go. But don’t stay slow forever, either. You still need to bring the transition back to the song’s tempo and rhythm. Playing something slowly is preparation for playing it in context—not a replacement for it.

Then Practice Not Stopping

Once that transition is working, put it back into a larger section. Eventually, play through the song without stopping.

Now the assignment has changed. You’re no longer examining every movement. You’re training your body to keep playing, even when something doesn’t come out exactly as planned. Keep following the pulse. Miss a note? Catch the next chord. Find your place and continue.

Recovering is a skill, too. If you stop and restart every time something goes wrong in practice, that can become your response during a performance. You need opportunities to practice continuing—not because the mistake doesn’t matter, but because the music still needs somewhere to go.

But Don’t Rehearse the Same Mistake

There’s an important difference between an occasional slip and a mistake that happens in the same place every time.

If you keep stumbling over the same transition, playing through it repeatedly isn’t fixing it. You may be practicing the very movement you want to change.

YOU’RE PRACTICING TO MAKE MISTAKES.

I’m not talking about one missed note or suggesting that every mistake becomes permanent. Mistakes are part of learning. I’m talking about repeating the same unresolved movement without examining what’s going wrong.

Finish the play-through if that’s your assignment, but don’t spend the rest of practice repeating the same problem and hoping it disappears. Rewind. Head back into the trenches. Make the section smaller, slow the metronome down, and figure out what needs to change. Then build it back up and try another uninterrupted play-through.

Final Thought

Good practice needs both kinds of work: the patience to stop and fix something, and the confidence to keep moving when a mistake happens. The metronome helps with both—it gives you a steady reference while you rebuild a transition, and a pulse to follow while you practice continuing.

In the trenches, give the details your attention. During a play-through, give the music your commitment. And when the same mistake keeps coming back, recognize the signal: there’s still some work waiting for you down in the trenches.

Happy strumming —

Dr. Trey

Further Reading

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *